Opinion: Winter fuel payment cut is wrong

The UK Labour Government’s decision to end universal winter fuel payments are particularly concerning for Montgomeryshire, a rural area where cold winters and reliance on heating significant issues for many residents. Previously, payments were automatically made in November or December. Those still eligible will receive letters in the coming weeks.

Winter fuel payments have long been a lifeline for pensioners, helping to offset the high costs of heating their homes during the coldest months. As the energy price cap looks set to rise, the reduction in this support will hit vulnerable residents hard, with far-reaching impacts on the community.

  Other Trending Stories

• More snow on the way!
• Permission to create new holiday lodges refused
• Town councillors to consider motion to protect landmark
• Youth rep could become full councillor

The changes mean around 400,000 households, and 540,000 Welsh pensioners now not receiving up to £300 this winter. It is estimated that over 20,000 pensioners in Montgomeryshire and Glyndwr alone, will now not be receiving the winter fuel payment.

The Labour Party’s own research is suggesting that scrapping universal payments could lead to an increase in excess deaths by almost 4,000 people this winter. As Welsh Conservatives, we submitted a Senedd motion calling on the UK Government to reverse its decision to end the universal winter fuel payment, which all Senedd members voted on. I voted in favour of the motion, but unfortunately, Labour Senedd members voted against.

I believe the decision by the UK Government is the wrong one. About 10 million older people across the UK will no longer qualify for the benefit, which is worth between £100 and £300, because they are deemed too wealthy. However, this is not the case and determining who qualifies as "wealthy" can be complex. We have seen news stories of some pensioners missing out on the benefit because their weekly pension is over the threshold by just £2.

The process of means testing may not always fairly reflect an individual’s financial needs, especially given that wealth is often tied to property values, which may not accurately represent disposable income. The cost of living varies across the UK, meaning that pensioners in areas with high property values but moderate disposable income could be unfairly excluded from the Winter Fuel Payment under means-testing criteria. Given that energy prices are volatile, even pensioners considered “wealthy” by income or asset measures could be vulnerable to future surges in energy costs. It’s reported that the energy price cap will rise by 10% this winter. The loss of the Winter Fuel Payment could exacerbate financial strain in the future.

Montgomeryshire Pensioners will feel the pain of these cuts, this winter. Montgomeryshire's geographical landscape is largely rural, with a significant portion of the population living in older, less energy-efficient homes. In many cases, these homes rely on oil or solid fuel heating, which is not only expensive but also lacks the flexibility of modern energy systems.

For many elderly residents in Montgomeryshire, this payment has been a critical part of budgeting for the winter months, allowing them to maintain a basic standard of living during the cold weather. Many of these pensioners are on fixed incomes, with limited access to additional financial support. When you're already managing a tight household budget, any reduction in income can cause real anxiety.

Given the importance of this issue to Montgomeryshire, it is essential our Labour MP puts pressure on the now Labour UK Government to reconsider these cuts. Rural communities need more support, not less, particularly as we face the ongoing challenges of rising energy costs and an aging population. It is critical to highlight the unique challenges faced by Montgomeryshire and similar rural areas, ensuring that policies like the Winter Fuel Payment are designed with their needs in mind.

Without urgent action, many pensioners in Montgomeryshire could face a harsh winter, battling both the cold and the financial burden of trying to stay warm. It's a reality that we must not allow to go unaddressed.

Russell George MS
Member of the Senedd for Montgomeryshire